top of page
All pizzas are cooked the traditional way in a stone oven.
Toppings available:
Meats - homemade sausage, pepperoni, ham, salami, bacon, homemade meatball, chicken
Veggies - fresh mushrooms, fresh green peppers, fresh onions, spinach, sliced fresh tomato, black olives, fresh garlic, homemade eggplant, pepperoncini
Cheeses - feta, ricotta
Other - pineapple, anchovies
Plain
fresh, homemade sauce & mozzarella
Small (12") . . . . . $12.40
Large (16") . . . . . $16.75
White Garlic
fresh garlic & mozzarella
Small (12") . . . . . $12.40
Large (16") . . . . . $16.75
Pesto
pesto & mozzarella
Small (12") . . . . . $12.40
Large (16") . . . . . $16.75
Sal's Special
homemade sausage, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, fresh green peppers, & extra mozzarella
Small (12") . . . . . $20.40
Large (16") . . . . . $28.75
Meat Lover
homemade sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, & mozzarella
Small (12") . . . . . $20.40
Large (16") . . . . . $28.75
Veggie
fresh green peppers, fresh mushrooms, fresh onions, black olives, & mozzarella
Small (12") . . . . . $20.40
Large (16") . . . . . $28.75
Chicken Wing
chicken with choice of mild, med, hot, bbq, honey bbq & mozzarella
Small (12") . . . . . $16.40
Large (16") . . . . . $22.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch
fresh garlic w/ chicken, bacon,
ranch dressing, & mozzarella
Small (12") . . . . . $20.40
Large (16") . . . . . $28.75
Cost of each additional topping
Small (12") . . . . . . . . . . . . . $2.00
Large (16") . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $3.00
Extra Dough . . . . . . . . . . . . . $3.00
Gluten Free Pizza
Gluten free pizzas are all 10".
Plain . . . . . . . . . . . $12.00
Topping . . . . . . . . . $1.25
Pizza by the Slice
Per Slice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $2.80
Each additional topping . . . $0.50
Calzones
All calzones are a single size (feeds 2-3 people), made with ricotta and mozzarella cheese & come with your choice of ONE topping (listed above).
$17.50
Each additional topping . . . $2.00
Chicken Wings
All chicken wings are served with blue cheese.
Mild ∙ Medium ∙ Hot ∙ BBQ ∙ Honey BBQ
Garlic Parmesan ∙ Garbage
Fresh garlic can be added to any sauce.
Traditional Chicken Wings
Boneless Chicken Wings
Extra Blue Cheese . . . . . . . . . . . $1.50
Extra Wing Sauce on side . . . . . $0.75
Dozen . . . . . . . $14.79
1/2 Dozen . . . . . $7.59
Dozen . . . . . . . $14.79
1/2 Dozen . . . . . $7.59
Build Your Own Pasta
Step 1: Choose Your Pasta ($9.25)
Spaghetti
Rigatoni
Step 2: Choose Your Sauce
Homemade Tomato Sauce
Pesto Sauce
Step 3: Choose Your Extras
Two Homemade Meatballs . . . . . $2.50
Homemade Sausage . . . . . . . . . . $3.00
Fresh Mushrooms . . . . . . . . . . . . $2.00
Melted Mozzarella . . . . . . . . . . . . $2.00
Italian Specialties
Homemade Lasagna
$11.79
baked homemade beef lasagna topped with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Stuffed Shells
$11.79
four baked ricotta stuffed shells topped with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Ravioli
$11.79
six baked ricotta ravioli topped with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Stuffed Manicotti
$11.79
three baked ricotta manicotti topped with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Manicotti Eggplant Combination
$11.79
one baked ricotta manicotti and fresh, homemade eggplant topped with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Dinners
All dinners come with ONE side: french fries, onion rings, spaghetti, or tossed salad.
Chicken Parmigiana / $13.89
breaded chicken cutlet topped with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Eggplant Parmigiana / $13.89
fresh, homemade eggplant topped with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Veal Parmigiana / $13.89
breaded veal cutlet topped with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Chicken Fillets / $13.89
breaded chicken fillets with your choice of sauce on the side (mild, medium, hot, bbq, honey bbq, marinara)
Seafood Combination / $13.89
red hook beer battered fried shrimp and fried haddock with tartar and cocktail sauces
Fish / $13.89
breaded fried haddock with tartar sauce
Shrimp / $13.89
red hook beer battered fried shrimp with cocktail sauce
Subs
All subs are served on locally baked French bread from Ithaca Bakery.
All subs are available in 8" and 12".
Hot
Hot Sausage
$9.99 / $12.25
fresh, homemade hot sausage with choice of sautéed green peppers, onions, & mushrooms
Pizza Burger
$9.99 / $12.25
fresh, homemade hot sausage, fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese with choice of sautéed green peppers, onions, & mushrooms
Meatball Parmigiana
$9.99 / $12.25
fresh, homemade meatballs with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Eggplant Parmigiana
$9.99 / $12.25
fresh, homemade eggplant with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Chicken Parmigiana
$9.99 / $12.25
breaded chicken cutlet with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Philly Cheese Steak
$9.99 / $12.25
thinly sliced angus beef sirloin grilled to perfection with american cheese with choice of sautéed green peppers, onions, & mushrooms
Fish
$9.99 / $12.25
breaded fried haddock with fresh lettuce, tomato, & side of tartar sauce
Chicken Wing
$9.99 / $12.25
breaded chicken cutlet with your choice of wing sauce (mild, medium, hot, BBQ, honey BBQ, garbage) & blue cheese or ranch
Chicken Cutlet
$9.99 / $12.25
breaded fried chicken cutlet with fresh lettuce, tomato, & mayonnaise
Tully Burger
$9.99 / $12.25
2 (1/4 lb patties), fresh tomato, lettuce, & american cheese
Veal Parmigiana
$9.99 / $12.25
breaded fried veal cutlet with fresh, homemade tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese
Cold
Turkey
$9.49 / $11.75
fresh lettuce, tomato, & mayonnaise
Ham
$9.49 / $11.75
fresh lettuce, tomato, & mayonnaise with american cheese
Italian Salami
$9.49 / $11.75
fresh lettuce, tomato, & mayonnaise with provolone cheese
Mixed Cold Cut
$9.49 / $11.75
fresh lettuce, tomato, & mayonnaise with italian salami, turkey, & ham with american cheese
Sandwiches
BLT
$4.75
bacon, fresh lettuce, & tomato served on white toast
Cheeseburger
$4.75
1/4 lb. patty served with american cheese on a sesame seed bun from Ithaca Bakery
Hamburger
$4.50
1/4 lb. patty served on a sesame seed bun from Ithaca Bakery
Tully Burger
$5.25
1/4 lb. patty served with american cheese with fresh lettuce, tomato, & mayonnaise on a sesame seed bun from Ithaca Bakery
Grilled Cheese
$3.00
served with american cheese on white bread
Grilled Ham & Cheese
$4.99
served with american cheese on white bread
Fish
$5.99
breaded fried haddock with fresh lettuce and tartar sauce on fresh Ithaca Bakery french bread
Side Orders
Basket of Shrimp
20 count; red hook beer battered shrimp served with cocktail sauce
$13.99
Onion Rings
breaded, fried onion rings
Small: $3.99
Large: $7.49
French Fries
classic cut french fries, fried to golden perfection
Small: $3.50
Large: $7.00
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
7 count; served with marinara sauce
$6.99
Jalapeño Poppers
6 count; served with marinara sauce
$6.99
Chicken Tenders
3 count; served with your choice of sauce
$6.99
Garlic Bread
6 count; garlic spread on fresh Ithaca Bakery french bread
$4.25
Garlic Bread w/ Cheese
6 count; garlic spread on fresh Ithaca Bakery french bread topped with mozzarella cheese
$5.25
Salads
Dressings: Blue Cheese, French, Italian, Ranch
Chicken Wing Salad
$9.99
tomato, black olive, pepperoncini with choice of: mild, medium, hot, bbq, honey bbq, garbage
Italian Antipasto
$9.99
tomato, black olive, pepperoncini with ham, salami, & provolone cheese
Chef Salad
$9.99
tomato, black olive, with ham, turkey, & american cheese
Greek Salad
$9.99
tomato, black olive, pepperoncini with feta cheese
Tossed Salad
$3.99
tomato, black olive, pepperoncini
Dessert
Fried Dough
made with our fresh pizza dough topped with powdered sugar
$4.99
Candy Bar
assorted candy bar options
$1.85
Catering Menu
REQUIRED: 24-HOUR ADVANCE NOTICE ON CATERING ORDERS
Sheet Pizza
Sheet Pizza . . . . $25.00
Each additional topping . . . . $5.00
Tossed Green Salad
1/2 tray (feeds 8 to 10) . . . . $25.00
full tray (feeds 18 to 22) . . . . $40.00
Rigatoni
1/2 tray (feeds 8 to 10) . . . . $25.00
full tray (feeds 18 to 22) . . . . $40.00
Rigatoni Parmigiana
1/2 tray (feeds 8 to 10) . . . . $35.00
full tray (feeds 18 to 22) . . . . $60.00
Chicken Parmigiana
1/2 tray (feeds 8 to 10) . . . . $45.00
full tray (feeds 18 to 22) . . . . $90.00
Homemade Eggplant Parmigiana
1/2 tray (feeds 8 to 10) . . . . $45.00
full tray (feeds 18 to 22) . . . . $90.00
Stuffed Shells
1/2 tray (feeds 8 to 10) . . . . . . . $45.00
full tray (feeds 18 to 22) . . . . . . . $90.00
Chocolate Chip Cookies
36 count . . . . . $50.00
Specials
Large Cheese Pizza and 1 Dozen Wings
$28.25
Boneless or Traditional
(Mild • Medium • Hot • BBQ • Honey BBQ • Garlic Parmesan • Garbage)
Fresh garlic can be added to any sauce.
Additional charge of $3.00 for each pizza topping.
Large Pizza with 2 Toppings
$19.75
Toppings available:
Meats - homemade sausage, pepperoni, ham, salami, bacon, homemade meatball, chicken
Veggies - fresh mushrooms, fresh green peppers, fresh onions, spinach, sliced fresh tomato, black olives, fresh garlic, homemade eggplant, pepperoncini
Cheeses - feta, ricotta
Other - pineapple, anchovies
bottom of page